LoAR

of the College of Arms
of the
Society for Creative Anachronism, Inc.

September 1991


THE FOLLOWING SUBMISSIONS HAVE BEEN REGISTERED:

ATENVELDT

Alessandra Raffaela di Luciano. Badge. Purpure, a winged scarab beetle displayed, between the wingtips a bezant and in chief a scimitar fesswise blade to chief Or.

The wings on this submission were not voided. They are however drawn in a post-Period stylized manner. Please ask the submitter to use more standard bird wings.

Artemisia, Principality of. Badge for Order of the Gryphon's Heart. Sable, a winged heart Or.

Beth of Atenveldt. Holding name and device (see RETURNS for name). Purpure, four hearts conjoined in annulo, points outward, agent and a bordure Or.

Submitted as Levia Rhys y Llawgwen.

Frances Blackstone. Device. Argent, an owl's head cabossed and three caltraps, one and two, sable.

Gareth ap Llewelyn. Badge for Warte Garde. Purpure, an open padlock and in base a key reversed, fracted chevronwise inverted Or.

Ivan Howard of Hightower. Name and device. Gules, a bend dovetailed between four crosses bottony fitchy argent all within a bordure Or.

Jahan Isfahani. Name.

James of Durmast. Name.

As with the name Daria of Durmast, registered August 1991, although Durmast itself dates only to 1791, Lord Dragon made a good case for it as a constructed name from period elements.

Jean André Boeye. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Jean Pierre du Roche. Name and device. Argent, a bend sinister dovetailed vert between three fleurs-de-lys and a sword bendwise sinister inverted gules.

Joscelin de Lyons. Name.

Jocelyn Douglas of Fairfax. Badge (See RETURNS for household name). Purpure, on a scroll argent an hourglass sable and on a chief argent a dolmen of three lintels sable.

John the Idiota. Badge. Sable, a monkey sejant erect affronty, in chief an annulet Or.

Versus the badge of Kyra Kai ferch Madoc, submitted in the LOI, there is a letter of permission to conflict.

Judith Anne of Durmast. Name.
As with the name Daria of Durmast, registered August 1991, although Durmast itself dates only to 1791, Lord Dragon made a good case for it as a constructed name from period elements.

Katerina O'Callaghan. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Kenneth MacQuarrie. Name.

Kyra Kay ferch Madoc. Badge. Sable, a monkey sejant erect affronty, in chief a crescent argent.

Versus John the Idiota, submitted in this LOI, there is a letter of permission to conflict.

Lucrezia Maria de Vallombrosa. Name.

Michael DeLacy. Name.

Michael Joseph La Mano Dolce. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Miranda the Seamstress. Badge. Sable, three needles in pile points conjoined within a bordure argent.

Morgan ferch Cennydd. Device. Sable, a bend argent goutty de sang between two hawks' heads erased that to chief contourny argent.

Nels Ulfger i Jaren. Name and device. Vert, a chevron rompu Or between three wolves' heads cabossed argent.

The given name was documented on the LoI only from Kolatch. As a number of my predecessors have stated many times, KOLATCH IS NOT ACCEPTABLE FOR DOCUMENTATION! Please do not use it in the future! Fortunately, several commenters were able to document Nels from reliable sources. Nice device!

Niniane Ende. Device. Per bend sinister vert and azure, a threaded needle fesswise Or and a winged lion sejant erect argent.

Orin the Late. Badge. [Fieldless] A kraken gules charged with a goutte d'eau.

Petruccio Alfonso Maria Cuccieri de Cataluña. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Submitted as Petruccio Alfonso Maria Cuccieri de Catalonia, we have modified the locative so that it agrees in language with the particle.

Ragnvald Bloodaxe. Name.

Raymond Carder the Sea Rover. [Fieldless] On a rudder purpure, an equal armed Celtic cross saltirewise Or.

While this is the first one in the SCA, rudders are a Period charge.

Rhodri Longshanks. Badge. Gules, three ermine tails conjoined in pall argent between three crescents horns outward Or.

Samuron the Inconsistent. Name and device. Per pale rayonny Or and sable, a sun gules and an increscent argent.

Please inform the submitter to draw the line of division with larger and fewer rayonny traits.

Svetlana Gunnarsdottir. Name change from holding name of Melanie of Atenveldt.

Titus the Alchemist. Name and badge (see RETURNS for device). Vert, a ferret statant guardant to sinister argent.

Versus Orien Wenderson, Vert, a hedgehog statant to sinister argent, the consensus of the commentary was that X.2. applies between ferrets and hedgehogs.

Ucko D'Aosta. Name and device. Per chevron inverted argent and azure, in chief a caltrap gules.

Varia the Wolf Slayer. Name and device. Sable, a tree blasted and eradicated argent between two harps Or all within a snake involved in orle argent.

Varia the Wolf Slayer. Badge. Sable, two harps interlaced in bend sinister within a bordure Or.

Versus Rosalie Harper (SCA), Sable, three harps within a bordure Or, there is a CVD for changing the number of primary charges and a second for the change in position (and interlacing) of the remaining two.

William Bauer. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Wolfgang of Three Needles. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Wulfric of Santlache. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

ATLANTIA

Alaric Halden. Name and device. Argent, on a pile issuant from dexter chief azure a maltese cross palewise argent.

Alethea bint Fahd ibn Akhtar. Name and device. Per saltire azure and Or, in chief an estoile of four greater and four lesser rays argent, in fess two natural panthers combattant azure and in base an estoile of four greater and four lesser rays Or.

Alewyn Adair. Name and device. Per fess azure and argent two acorns argent and an oak leaf vert.

Annabella Kirkpatrick. Name.

Artus Falconieri. Name.

Aubrey Gawen. Device. Per chevron azure and gules, a falcon's head erased argent within a bordure Or.

Brynna of Aelfstanbury. Name and badge for Aelfstan's Hall. [Fieldless] A raven, displayed sable perched upon a sword fesswise reversed Or.

Cathgal Staunton. Name.

Catriona the Lame. Device. Argent, a crutch sable within a bordure azure.

Ceara Ó Toughill. Name.

Ciarnat de Ráth an Iúir. Name.

Cunen Beornhelm. Name and device. Argent, a hind courant gules, on a point pointed sable a crescent Or.

Désiré of Attillium. Name and device. Per bend sable and gules, a bend embattled counter-embattled argent between a lightning bolt bendwise Or and an owl argent.

Dughall of Cathanar. Holding name and device (see RETURNS for name). Per pale gules and sable, three lizards tergiant fesswise embowed to base argent.

Submitted as Dughall MacDhomhnuill.

Elisabeth des Monts Argents. Name change from Héléne de Chateau Montargent.

Elisabeth of Bedford. Device. Ermine, vetú azure, a brown horse couchant proper blazed and stockinged argent.

Submitted as Elizabeth, when this was registered in 1989 it was spelled with an "s".

Fergus of Hanna. Name.

Fergus Smythson. Name and device. Quarterly azure and Or, a mullet of four points counterchanged.

Fiadnat ní Chonchobair. Name and device. Per pale wavy sable and argent, a doe and a wolf salient respectant.

Hreodbeorht MacBeath. Name.

János of Cyddlain Downs. Name and device. Azure, three dice within a bordure argent.

Lochmere, Barony of. Name for the Order of the Blasted Oak.

Malcolm MacMalcolm. Name and device. Azure, on a bezant a crab gules within a bordure Or.

Marina of Rathlin. Device. Per pale azure and Or, two pithons erect addorsed counterchanged.

Meghan Pengwyn of Wynterwood. Name and badge for House Wynterwood. Per pale vert and argent, three holly leaves conjoined in pall inverted counterchanged.

Meraud de Dun Carraig. Device. Vert, two chevronels between three compass stars and an angel facing sinister drawing a bow Or.

Morgan Cynwyl y Cerddor. Name and device. Purpure, a pall Or between a decrescent transfixed by an arrow inverted and two swans naiant respectant argent.

Neapsford, Canton of. Name.

Nygell Tallis. Device. Vert, a winged boar segreant argent within a bordure engrailed Or charged with three pairs of acorns vert.

Nygell Tallis. Badge. [Fieldless] On a tree couped proper, a winged boar segreant argent.

Óengus Mac Mhíolchon. Name.

Olga Forgalwoman. Device. Azure, on a plate between three escallops argent, a bottlenosed dolphin naiant azure.

Submitted as Olga Forgal's Woman, the name was registered as above in the June LoAR.

Patricia Matthis. Name and device. Per bend vert and azure, a bend invected on the upper edge and engrailed on the lower edge between an escallop and a hippocampus Or.
The bend invected on one edge and engrailed on the other is not very good style, though it is probably within the parameters of acceptability for the SCA.

Ranulf D'Arcy. Name and device. Per bend sinister purpure and gules, a sword inverted proper between two towers in bend argent, a chief embattled Or.

Ricchar Raven's Claw. Name.

Richard of Sterling. Name.

Richenda Bevilacqua. Name and device. Pean, a raven displayed and on a chief argent three decrescents sable.
Nice armory!

Robert the Forgotten. Name and device. Azure, two arrows inverted in chevron Or between three gouttes argent.

Starulf Haraldsson of Ravenspur. Name.

Taliesin ap Owaine. Name and device. Vert, a sea horse contourny within an orle to of crescents argent.

Temair MacDiarmada. Name.

Therasa du Domremy. Change of name from Therasa Perna du Domremy and badge. [Fieldless] A garb vert surmounted by a honeybee Or.

CAID

Aleksandra Ivanovna Molotova. Name and device. Azure, a warhammer bendwise sinister argent, in base a duck naiant Or, all within a bordure argent.

Submitted as Aleksandra Ivanovna Molotov, we have modified the name to correct the grammar.

Arriel of Andros. Name.

Artemas the Innkeeper. Device. Vert, a rabbit's head erased contourny argent.

Brian mac Rannall of Graig na Manach. Name.

Bríd uí Chon na Mara. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Submitted as Bríd uí Con na Mara, we have modified the name to correct the grammar.

Bryanna Marie Joyce Shannon. Device. Azure, crusilly Latin Celtic flory Or, two winged lions sejant respectant argent.

Calafia, Barony of. Badge. [Fieldless] A flame within and conjoined at the base to a goutte voided Or.

Calafia, Barony of. Badge for Order of the Golden Trident. [Fieldless] A trident's head within and conjoined to an annulet Or.

Calafia, Barony of. Badge for Order of the Serpent's Talon. [Fieldless] A dragon's jambe couped inverted Or.

Cassandra Northcliffe. Device. Vert, three lamps and a chief double-arched Or.

Catherine Jane Page. Name.

Catherine of Cobweb Cottage. Name and device. Gules, a sea-pegasus passant, on a chief argent two dolphins naiant gules.

Catriona Muireaghan of Carlingford. Name change from Catriona Muireaghan of Carlingford Lough and badge. [Fieldless] A shamrock per pale vert and argent.

Cedrych Ladyman. Device. Per saltire argent and Or, a cup azure and on a chief sable three mullets of six points argent.

Ceridwen Luned of the Fen. Name and device. Sable, a winged sea-tiger argent marked sable, winged and tailed, a base wavy Or.

Ciaran Faol Ruath. Badge. [Fieldless] A wolf rampant reguardant contourny gules.

Ciar Lasse MacGregor. Device. Sable, a equal-armed Celtic cross potent and on a chief Or three annulets sable.

Tadhg Liath of Duncairn has kindly given the submitter a letter of permission to conflict.

Collawyn Lughaid O'Cearbhaill. Name for Collawyn's Cohorts.

Cyfyn o Aper Mynuy ap Gwilym. Name.

Dabhaidh Earmourer the Tiny. Device. Argent, a double-horned anvil sable, in chief two smith's hammers in chevron proper and a base rayonny sable.

Damales Redbeard. Name for Maison du Cheval Volant.

Elana Blakefenn. Device. Vert, on a plate a cat couchant to sinister sable within a bordure rayonny argent.

Although the mini emblazon had some problems, the large emblazon clearly matched the submitted blazon.

Elizabeth Scott of Berwick and Jonas Aquilian. Badge. [Fieldless] A rose per pale sable and argent barbed and seeded proper.
Versus William of York (SCA) Per pale sable and argent, a rose unbarbed seeded counterchanged. There is one CVD for fieldlessness and a second for reversing the order of the tinctures on the primary.

Elspeth ni Conchobhair o Ciarraighe. Badge. [Fieldless] An increscent moon lozengy argent and azure.

Emrys Montgomery. Name.

Eoin MacCumhail. Name and device. Per fess argent and gules, a sinister hand counterchanged.

Fréderic de Cherbourg. Name and device. Or, an apple and on a chief gules a griffin passant Or.

Giles Hill of Sweetwater. Device change. Azure, on a saltire invected Or, two keys fretted with a mascle sable and a bordure argent.

The submitter's currently registered device, Azure, on a saltire invected Or, two keys fretted with a mascle sable and on a chief argent a label azure, is released.

Gwynevere of Riesling. Device. Vert, semy of butterflies, a point pointed Or.

Gyldenholt, Barony of. Badge. [Fieldless] An oak leaf Or, overall two arrows in saltire azure.

Hydyr ferch Caradoc Llanfairynghornwy. Name and device. Argent, a sword inverted purpure, overall a sprig of heather bendwise sinister vert flowered and a bordure purpure.

Submitted as Hydyr ferch Caradoc y Llanfairynghornwy, we have modified the name to correct the grammar.

Joanna Melissa Ronsivalle. Name and device. Or, in pale two bottlenosed dolphins naiant, that in chief contourny, sable.

Kendrick Ostler. Name and device. Vert, three horseshoes inverted argent and a chief Or.

Kurt von Arriksleva. Device. Quarterly Or and sable, in saltire a crossbow quarrel inverted sable and a quill pen Or.

Linnet le Mercier. Name.

Llywelyn Gwehydd Pentrelasleygercaerdydd ap Gwilym. Name and badge for Caerlonydd. [Fieldless] A castle sable charged with three celtic crosses Or.

Lura Maureen of Burthoswald. Name change from Audrey MacAlise of Roslindale and device change. Argent, a war hammer sable and on a chief nebuly gules three plates.

Her old device, Argent, a bend sinister compony azure and Or between a sprig of white ash bendwise sinster vert and a rose gules, barbed and seeded proper, is released.

Martyn ap Cadwalladr the Bold. Badge. [Fieldless] On a sun Or a cross crosslet fitchy gules.
Regarding Bruce of Brandy Hall (SCA), Purpure, on a sun in its splendor Or, a dagger gules, there is a CVD for fieldlessness and under the ruling regarding X.4.j.ii.a, made at the July Laurel Meeting, a second for a change to type of tertiary on a sun. (note: the cover letter with the August LoAR requested commentary regarding the application of X.4.j.ii to tertiaries on a sun. Hence, this registration should not be taken as the final word on this subject.)

Megan Ramsey. Name change from Megan Maria Gonzaga.

Morgan Kildarby. Name and device. Per fess argent and sable, a crescent and a wolf rampant counterchanged.

Mwynen Lynnette Chartier. Device change. Gules, a pomegranate argent, slipped and leaved vert, between four fleurs-de-lys in cross Or.

Her current device, Sable, two needles in saltire, points to base, Or within a bordure argent semy of roses purpure, barbed and seeded proper, is released.

Raphael of Silverdale. Name.

Raven of Heronsmarsh. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Robynne the Grey. Device. Argent, three garbs purpure within a bordure gules.

Sarah of Dun Or. Name.

Tadhg O'Murchadha the Wanderer. Name and device. Argent, a harp reversed sable and a chief indented vert.

Versus, Boadicea Artemesia (SCA) Argent, a Greek lyre sable. There is a CVD for the addition of the chief (which needs to be drawn much wider) and another (just) for the difference in type of primary charge.

Tamar bint Ephraim al-Haa'ika. Name change from Tamar bat Ephraim and device. Lozengy vert and argent, on a chief argent two roses purpure, slips nowed together in a Wake knot proper.
Period instances of Jews in Muslim Spain combining Hebrew names with the Arabic patronymic give credence to this form.

Tamar bint Ephraim al-Haa'ika. Badge. Lozengy vert and argent, a rose purpure and a bordure gules.

Thomas Brownwell. Badge. [Fieldless] A goutte barry wavy azure and argent.

Thorgrim macDrostáin of the Cornovii. Name.

Submitted as Thorgrim macDrosten of the Cornovii, we have modified the name to correct the grammar.

Timothy Royar. Name and badge for Tribulus Company. Per fess gules and sable, a caltrap argent.
Nice armory!

Toirdhealbhach MacMathghamhain. Name and device. Per pale gules and Or, two bears combattant maintaining battles-axes counterchanged.

Tostig Locksbane. Name and device. Per fess gules and sable, a fess embattled between three open padlocks and a dragon's head erased contourny Or.

The byname is unlikely. The period term picklock is a much more plausible epithet.

Ulfric Osler of Land's End. Name and device. Per saltire sable and gules, a tree blasted between two wolves rampant addorsed argent.

Virginia le Swann. Name and device. Purpure, a swan naiant argent between four mullets in cross Or.

Pretty device!

Xantha of Greystone Keep. Name.

CALONTIR

Alessia di Lago del Cigno. Badge. [Fieldless] A lemon Or semy of cloves sable.

Bebhinn o Dubhlain. Device. Argent, two pallets purpure and on a chief vert, a snowflake argent.

Donatus Luxford. Device. Or, two spears in saltire sable surmounted by a dragon salient to sinister gules.

Erik Aarskog. Name.

Fiammetta Attavanti. Name and device. Gyronny azure and Or, an opinicus statant gules.

Versus Taliba bint Ihsan (SCA), [Fieldless] An opinicus passant gules, wings displayed vert, it was the consensus of those at the Laurel meeting that the changes to the wings of tincture and position were sufficient for the necessary second CVD.

Gwendolyn Morna O'Shaughnessey. Name and device. Per bend gules and sable, a horse rampant and a sword bendwise inverted argent.
Versus Edric the Forester (SCA), Per bend gules and sable, two spears in saltire and a sword argent hilted of leather proper, there is a CVD for type of half the charges and another for orientation of the other half (Edric's sword is clearly palewise).

Ian Michael O'Shaughnessey. Name (see RETURNS for device).

Moriagh Teige O'Flaithbheartaigh. Device. Or, on a fountain a crocodile involved gules.

Moriagh Tiege O'Flaithbheartaigh. Badge. [Fieldless] A crocodile involved gules.

Siubhan Catriona Guinne. Device. Azure, two bendlets wavy Or between an escallop and a dolphin haurient argent.

Wulfstan Schwarzwolf. Name.

Submitted as Wulfstan Schwarzenwolf, we have modified the name to correct the grammar to give the submitter what he desired.

Valerian Sharpe Boncore. Name.

EAST

Alys van Schaack of Lynnencorre. Name change from Alys of Lynnencorre.

Duncan Forbes. Name change from holding name of Duncan Forbes.

The submitter wishes to officially register what has been his holding name.

Etienne de Lyons. Correction of blazon. Azure, on a pale Or between two lions combattant and in chief two crosses flory argent, three fleurs-de-lys sable.
The word Or was omitted from the blazon when his arms were registered in April, 1988.

Guenddoleu MacAodhagáin. Name and device. Azure, three candles argent enflamed proper and on a chief argent four annulets azure.

Guillaume de Vosges. Name.

Gwenneth ferch Gwalchmai. Name.

Harpelestane, Shire of. Name and device. Per saltire Or and gules, a laurel wreath vert between in cross four towers counterchanged.

Hunter's Home, Shire of. Name and device. Purpure, three chalices within a laurel wreath Or.

Ice Valley, Shire of. Name.

Jairus of the Darklands. Name.

James Allen of Concordia. Device. Vert, a ram's head couped contourny and on a chief argent three maltese crosses gules.

James Edmund of Aberedw. Name.

Jan Friederich van Schaack. Name.

Jaric de l'Ile Longe Sault. Name.

Submitted as Jaric d'Ile Longe Sault Name, we have modified the name to make it a generic locative rather than the specific post period name.

Jotun-Eirikr Bjarnason. Device. Vert, two axes in saltire addorsed surmounted by a double-bitted axe palewise, in chief three mullets, all within a bordure Or.

Justin the Fair. Name and device. Argent, ermined azure, a bend azure and overall a sword sable.

Katharynne Reede. Device. Vert, a Catherine wheel argent and a chief rayonny Or.

Katherine de Cressy. Name.

Keara Caitlin MacLeod. Name and device. Or, in pale a thistle proper and a mace and a sword in saltire sable.

This is technically just not slot machine heraldry, but only because visually there are two charge "groups", rather than one group of three different charges. [Irreverent comment from the Laurel Meeting: "Thistle while you hurt"?!?]

Kiely MacAra. Name.

Konrad Ragnarsson. Name.

Liam MacAodhagáin. Name.

Linnet of Suffolk. Name.

Mairghread of Ryvel. Name.

Malachi Trett. Name.

Malkah Rozana Blaznowa. Device. Argent, mullety, on a pale azure two roses argent.
Striking armory!

Manfred de Outremer. Badge. [Fieldless] A tower argent goutty de sang.

Maria Erika von Ossenheim. Name.

Marian O'Liam. Device. Per saltire argent and vert, in pale two garden rosebuds slipped and leaved azure and in fess two trees blasted and eradicated argent.

Marion Howard. Name and device. Gules, crusilly fitchy, a sea horse and a chief wavy argent.
Pretty device!

Martin Lewis. Name.

Matteo Sassetti. Name change from Seumas O'Dale.

Melisande de la Mer. Name.

Morgan of Caer Graeme. Device. Argent, on a pale cotised between four roses sable barbed and seeded vert, an cubit arm armored argent.

Muhallim ibn Rashid. Name and device. Argent, a dromedary statant contourny sable and on a chief wavy azure two falcons striking respectant argent.

Nicholas of Blackheath. Name and device. Argent, on a bend sinister vert a compass rose palewise argent.
Nice device!

Padraig Dubh MacEanruig. Name.

Pont Alarch, Shire of. Name and device. Per bend embattled gules and ermine, a swan's head erased argent and a laurel wreath vert.

Ragnar MacHardy. Name and device. Per pale gules and Or, a wolf rampant to sinister and in chief two wheels counterchanged.

Rioghnach Ninian uerch Rhys. Name.

Robert of Ferness. Device. Per chevron chevronelly Or and gules, and Or, in base a ship in full sail gules, all within a bordure embattled sable.

Roger Honfleur. Name.

Rose the Riotous. Name only (see PENDING for device).

["It were better dwelle in dessert, than with a womman that Is riotous." Chaucer]

Ruantallan, Barony of. Name for Order of the Iceberg.
While the English term "iceberg" is clearly post-Period, given the large number of cognates in so many northern European languages we feel that the name is probably acceptable.

Sorcha Chathasach. Device. Argent, a harp vert between three foxes courant gules within a bordure dovetailed vert.

Talon the Bastard. Name.

Thomas of Aldridge. Name.

Thora Sharptooth. Blazon correction. Gules, three square weaver's tablets in bend Or.

The majority of the commenters favored changing the blazon of these charges from delfs pierced two and two to square weavers tablets. This then is the defining example of square weaver's tablets (with four holes, one in each corner). There are examples of weaver's tablets in other shapes and with other numbers of holes. If used, these other forms must be specifically blazoned.

Thorkil ap Llwyd. Name and badge. [Fieldless] A dragon's jambe couped gules.

Tiva the Horsetamer. Name.

Torquil McLeod. Name and device. Per bend sinister argent and gules, a bull's head cabossed and a heart counterchanged.

Ulrich von Wulfskuhl. Name and device. Per bend nebuly azure and argent, a heart and a decrescent counterchanged.

Uther Shieldbreaker. Name and device. Per saltire argent and azure, in fess two dogs combattant argent.

Veleda of Dalriata. Name.

Vladimir Runemaker the Wicked. Name.

Winifred de Schyppewallebotham. Name change from Fionnghuala Siobhan nic an Chlerich.

MERIDIES

Agnes of the Whispering Willows. Device. Per fess engrailed Or and azure, three gouttes azure and three crosses flory Or all within a bordure embattled gules.

The charges were blazoned on the LoI with the tinctures reversed, but the vast majority of commenters caught that fact.

Alexander Ravenscroft. Name.

Bébinn an Ghleanna. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Fergus O'Kelly. Name.

Gareth Cunedda. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Gwenddolynn ni hAilleachaín. Name.

Gwenhwyfar de Hwytinton. Name.

Holleigh Falcon. Name and device. Argent, a falcon azure, hooded, jessed and belled gules, within an orle of holly leaves vert, fructed gules.

Ian McChattan. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Submitted as Ian Chattan, we have modified the name to what the submitter originally wanted. Lord Dragon produced some good evidence for registering the form which the submitter originally desired.

Sven Förlorad. Name.
Submitted as Sven Förlust, we have modified the name to correct the grammar. Förlust is the noun "loss"; the desired meaning is Förlurad.

MIDDLE

Aelfric Cautus. Name.

Cynwrig the Wanderer. Name.

Ceridwen of Ulgham. Name.

Erich von Plauen. Name and device. Per chevron Or and argent, a pick and a Maltese cross sable.

Please tell the submitter to draw the "per chevron" line higher on the shield. As it stands this is perilously close to a point pointed, which in this case would be metal on metal.

Greyfells, Canton of. Device. Argent, on a pile purpure a sunburst Or, overall a laurel wreath vert.

Gunter Wahlstedt. Device. Per pale argent and sable, a tower between three crescents counterchanged.

Jeremy Adrian the Vain. Name.

Johann LaRue von Metz. Name and device. Gules, a dragon's head within and issuant from the base of a mascle throughout Or.

As drawn on the large emblazon "mascle" was more of "mini-scule". Please inform the submitter that the mascle needs to be drawn even wider than it was on the mini-emblazon on the LoI.

Justinian Clarus. Augmentation of device. Azure, on a bend sinister embattled counterembattled voided humetty plain between two columns argent, a straight trumpet Or, and in augmentation the column in dexter chief enfiled by an annulet Or.

Katharina Alexandra Zrinski. Name and device. Checky gules and argent, a catamount couchant sable.

Kirsten Thorsteinsdottir. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Ragnar Karlson. Device. Paly gules and argent, an owl passant wings displayed inverted sable brandishing an axe palewise Or.

The axe in this submission, nearly the length of the primary charge, is significant enough to contribute to difference. Thus, this is clear from all of the "field, an eagle displayed sable" conflict calls. Please tell the submitter to draw the bird in a more standard heraldic "displayed" position rather than the slightly trian aspect shown here.

Reginald de Sheppey. Device. Ermine, a cross flory per pale gules and azure within a bordure per pale azure and gules.
Pretty device!

Rigunth af Bern. Name.

Timothy O'Byrne. Name.

Toirrdelbach Ua Máel Doraid. Name.

Vali the Black Wanderer. Name and device. Argent, a devil decapitated statant affronty, his head affronty on his chest, vert and in canton a scarpe enhanced azure.

WEST

Adriana nic Aífe. Holding name and device (see RETURNS for name). Per pale vert and azure, a hawk's head erased argent between three suns Or.

Submitted as Adriana nic Aífe de Winterhawke.

Aidan of Sicily. Name and device. Vert, two daggers in saltire Or, a base of flame proper.

Alfar of Attica. Name and device. Per chevron sable and gules, three mullets one and two Or, and a sword proper.

Allissandra Olympia Martiessa de Constantine. Release of household name Harpyhold.

Anthony fitz Robert. Device. Per fess Or and vert, on a pale counterchanged, between in chief two martlets, in base a martlet vert.

Versus Cliffe (Papworth, p. 329), Argent, three popinjays vert, and the other suggested conflict calls, this is sufficiently different by the addition of primary charge (the pale).

Austyn of Forrestgate. Name and device. Per chevron sable and gules, three crescents conjoined in pall inverted, horns outward Or.
Versus Maurya Etain Sableswan, (Fieldless) Three crescents conjoined in pall horns outward Or, there is one CVD for fieldlessness and a second for what amounts to in pall inverted versus in pall.

Bruno de Brest. Name.

Caelainn nic Lochlainn. Name.

The bulk of the commentary favored registration of this name as being sufficiently different from Caitilin ni Lochlainn. Lord Laurel agrees that if correctly pronounced the two names are indeed sufficiently different. The problem, however, is the consistent mispronounciation of names in the SCA, not just by heralds (even sometimes by senior heralds. Isn't that right, Lady Harpy?) but by the submitters themselves. Given the overwhelming support of the commenters in the College, I am registering this in spite of my personal qualms about how each submitter (and the heralds in their respective areas) is pronouncing each name.

Catriona Eveleen Kilgannon. Device. Or, a garden rosebud gules slipped and leaved within an orle of shamrocks vert.

Christopher Anselm of Windsor. Device. Per chevron gules and azure, a chevron argent between two lions rampant Or, and a pig-faced bascinet argent.

Daniel the Willing. Name.

Danielle of Dragonfly Pond. Device. Argent, a dragonfly azure.

David ben Avraham Brisk. Name change from holding name of David of Caer Darth and badge. [Fieldless] A goutte erminois.

Deirdre of Cuailgne. Name and device. Vert, a fleam between three trefoils Or.

Eirik Hardradi. Device. Argent, a bend sinister cotissed between two ravens rising to sinister, wings addorsed and inverted, sable.

Falan Bitor. Badge. Gules, on a mallet argent, a rose, its stem entwined about the haft azure, a bordure argent.

Fanya of Thistlewood. Name and device. Per chevron Or and argent, two hearts gules and a cat's head erased azure.

Geoffrey Michaelson. Name and device. Or, a winged lion statant to sinister, in chief five mill rinds gules.

Giles Chadwik Richardson. Device. Per pale argent and azure, a tower and on a chief sable, three bezants.

Guinevere of Seal Cove. Name and device. Azure, a winged fox sejant erect affronty wings displayed and in chief five mullets argent.

Hadassah bat Yisrael. Name correction from Hassadah bat Yisrael.

This was already corrected in the LoAR of June 1991.

Iain James MacLaren. Name and device. Azure, a sword inverted bendwise sinister between a decrescent and an increscent all within a bordure embattled argent.

Iathus of Scara. Badge. [Fieldless] A goute vair.

Ileana del Mar. Device. Quarterly azure and vert, a horse passant to sinister argent.

Nice, simple armory.

Isaac of Damascus. Name and device. Purpure, two swords in saltire argent, in base a cauldron Or.

Jeanne of Audierne. Name change from Jeanne d'Audierne.

Mairghread Ellis nic Néill of Barra. Name and device. Or, on a pale sable, between two thistles proper, a dragon rampant Or.

Marija MacAlpine. Name and device. Argent, in bend three hearts bendwise purpure.

Martin Chaucer. Name.

Michael of Caer Myrddin. Name and device. Per pale vert and Or, a falcon migrant bendwise sinister within a bordure counterchanged Or and sable.

Niobe Lais. Device. Vert, a domestic cat couchant argent and a bordure engrailed Or.

Olaf Oleson Bjorn. Name and device. Per chevron inverted gules and sable, a double-bitted axe and a crescent argent.

Paul Wickenden of Thanet. Device. Vert, on a bend sinister argent between two mullets of eight points Or, three crosses crosslet palewise vert.

Nice armory.

Riccardo della Torre d'Avorio. Name.

Scandal nic Mháiréide. Name change from Meabh Scandlach and device change. Vert, a crux ansata within a bordure argent.

Submitted as Scandal nic Mhairead, we have modified the name to correct the grammar. Her currently registered device, Purpure, on a bend sinister nebuly between two cruces ansatae argent, a scarpe vert, is released.

Scannal Alpin. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Sean Tracy of Newbury. Name and device. Gules, a chevron embattled Or, overall a pegasus salient argent.

Versus Christofer Brownsfeld (Papworth, p. 375), Gules, a chevron raguly of two bastons couped at the top Or, there is a CVD for the addition of the overall charge and another for the difference between a chevron embattled (throughout its length) and one with "two bastons couped at the top".

Sigurd Silfrulf. Name.
Submitted as Sigurd Silfriulf, we have modified the name to correct the grammar of the byname.

Stephan of Bellatrix. Name only (see RETURNS for device).
While the byname is not registerable under the current rules, it is grandfathered (Stephan is the son of Duke Paul of Bellatrix).

Stephen MacAlpine. Name only (see RETURNS for device).

Susanna of Nottingham. Name.

Thomas of Foxhaven. Badge. Argent, a fox's mask gules, a bordure purpure.

Thora Hvalven. Name.

Submitted as Thorra Hvalvinr, we have modified the name to correct the grammar to a form of what the submitter originally submitted.

Viola del Manto. Name and device. Per saltire vert and sable, on a pale argent, a cat sejant affronty vert.

West, Kingdom of. Title for Harpy Herald.

William of Wakefield. Name and device. Per pale Or and gules, on a chevron between three crosses formy, two crosses formy palewise, all counterchanged.

Wulfric of Creigull. Badge. [Fieldless] A goutte vert crusily Latin argent.

THE FOLLOWING SUBMISSIONS HAVE BEEN RETURNED:

ATENVELDT

Jean André Boeye. Device. Azure, a bend gules fimbriated between an eagle striking Or and a stag's head contourny erased argent.

Conflict with Caboga (Woodward), Azure, a bend gules. There is one CVD for the addition of the secondaries, but nothing for the fimbriation of the bend.

Jocelyn Douglas of Fairfax. Name for Societas Historum Mortum.
In addition to the name being, even in Latin, an obtrusively modern take-off of a movie title and not Period in style, the grammar is incorrect. The correct grammar would appear to be Societas Gestarum Scriptorum Mortuorum. (All this leaving aside the question, of course, as to whether the household's members are all dead.)

Katerina O'Callaghan. Device. Or, a fox's head contourny erased within a bordure potenty gules.
Conflict with Giselle Barrentree (SCA), Or, a gazelle's head erased contourny within a bordure potenty gules. There is one CVD for the change to the type of the critter's head, but X.2 cannot be applied here.

Levia Rhys y Llawgwen. Name.
While the LoI noted that Levia is "the submitters mundane Jewish given name" and that a conversion letter was attached for documentation, the only place that the name Levia appeared at all (besides the line marked "Society Name" on the client's form) was a single place on the conversion letter in Hebrew. We need documentation for Levia. Additionally, there appear to be some problems with the grammar of the Welsh byname. Proper construction would appear to drop the article "y", and appear as either Llawwen (which Lady Harpy noted "looks strange") or Llaw Wen (to avoid confusion with llawen, "cheerful").

Maechyll of Maelienydd. Name and device. Argent, on a bend sinister azure between a triangle inverted and a triangle sable, three Latin crosses palewise Or each charged with a rose gules.
The Welsh equivalent to Michael is Mihangel, not Maechyll. The given as submitted appears unlikely at best. The device is four layers which is not permitted, additionally it exceeds the rule of thumb for complexity of XIII.1.a with five tinctures and four types of charge.

Michael Joseph La Mano Dolce. Device. Per pale gules and sable, a tiger-headed torque, heads to base, Or striped sable.
Conflict with Le Valet au Cercle d'Or (Fabulous Heraldry p. 8), Purpure, a golden circlet banded sable. There is only one CVD for the change to the tincture of the field.

Nafisah bint I'sharqui. Name.
The submitter's appeal boiled down to using a highly eccentric spelling in order to approximate pronunciation of the byname. Standard orthography would transliterate "the Easterner" as al-Sharqi or al-Sharki. To keep the pronunciation as close to the Arabic as possible, it would normally be transliterated as ash-Sharqi or ash-Sharki. Since, as noted in the original return, as the submitter allows no changes we cannot correct the transliteration to one of the generally accepted systems to register the name. (Lord Laurel understands the objections of those commenters who note that the Administrative Handbook requires a summarization of supporting evidence to be included in the LoI. However, after reading through the submitter's documentation, had I been Lady Aten I'm not sure I would have known how to summarize it, either.)

Otherhill, Shire of. Badge for the Unicorn Guard. Gules, a unicorn's head to sinister erased argent, collared flory sable.
Submitted as [Fieldless] On a lozenge gules, ..., earlier Laurel precedents have noted that it is not permissible for a fieldless badge to contain a primary charge which is one of the standard shapes for heraldic display. A lozenge is specifically one of these shapes.
Conflict with Katrina of the Neverlands (SCA), Gules, a unicorn's head erased reversed and in canton a decrescent and in sinister chief in bend two mullets palewise argent. There is only one CVD for the deletion of the secondary charges.

Pawel of Gdansk. Badge. Purpure, a fasces Or.
Conflict with West, Kingdom of the, Court of Chancery, Azure, a fasces blade to sinister Or, tied gules. Although two commenters thought that this badge has been released, there is no notation to that effect in Laurel's files. If someone has documentation of its release (such as a dated LoAR), we would welcome confirmation. Until that time, however, this remains a conflict, with only one CVD for the tincture of the field.

Petruccio Alfonso Maria Cuccieri de Cataluña. Device. Azure, a Latin cross flory Or, veiled purpure, within a pair of wings in lure argent, in sinister chief two bendlets Or.
The purpure "veiling" over the cross, as an overall charge, should have good contrast with the field, which this does not. The use of two bendlets way up to one side severely unbalances the device. With four tinctures and four types of charge this is right at the limit of complexity. Combined with the use of what are normally central ordinaries as peripheral charges and the unusual treatment in the "veiling" of the cross, this must be returned for complexity and for non-Period style.

Titus the Alchemist. Device. Vert, in pale a ferret statant guardant to sinister argent and a mullet gyronny of ten argent and sable, within a bordure embattled Or.
Charges may not be gyronny of more than eight, per the LoAR of 22 March 1983. Would the submitter consider simply "a mullet argent"?

William Bauer. Device. Quarterly gules and Or, a mullet of four points elongated to base counterchanged.
Conflict with Eleanor Leonard (SCA), [Fieldless] A mullet of four points distilling from its lower point a goutte. There is a CVD for fieldlessness, but nothing else. See the Cover Letter with this LoAR for a further discussion of the "blanket letter of permission" written by Eleanor Leonard.

Wolfgang of Three Needles. Device. Vairy Or and gules, a fess sable, overall a sword within a bordure argent.
The sword lying as it does on the Or traits of the field is metal on metal. If the submitter would reverse the tinctures of the field so that the sword would then be lying on the gules traits (and draw the bordure a lot wider) this could be registered.

Wulfric of Santlache. Device. Sable, a chevron embattled between three hawk's legs couped contourny Or.
Conflicts with Tallant (Papworth, p. 455), Sable, a chevron between three eagle's legs erased Or. There is one CVD for embattling the chevron.

ATLANTIA

Dughall MacDhomhnuill.

Exact conflict with the already registered (May 1990) Dughall MacDhomhnuill.

Gerard FitzGerald. Device. Sable, a saltire dovetailed gyronny purpure and argent between four crescents argent.
There are two problems with this device. One is that the combination of a dovetailed line on a gyronny saltire is pretty clearly post-Period style. Even though the SCA has long allowed the use of dovetailed as compatible with our style, and has allowed the use of saltires gyronny, the combination seems obtrusively modern. (See RfS VIII.4.d.: "Generally modern style in the depiction of individual elements or the total design may not be registered.") The second problem is RfS VIII.3., Armorial Identifiability. The purpure portions of the saltire, with its complex line of division, fade so badly into the sable field that the identification of the primary charge is lost.

CAID

Bríd uí Chon na Mara. Device. Azure, on a bend bretessed between two open penannular brooches bendwise sinister Or, a bendlet vert.

Conflict with city of Armaugh, Urban District Council (Public Heraldry), Azure, on a bend embattled between in chief a primatal cross and in base a harp Or, a bendlet gules. There is only one CVD for the change to type of secondaries.

Cara Michelle DuValier. Device. Sable, four fleurs-de-lys in cross, bases to center, and a bordure Or.
Conflict with Lascelles (Papworth, p. 636), Sable, a cross flory within a bordure Or. Because of the arrangement of the primaries, we cannot apply X.2 to grant sufficient difference between this arrangement of four fleurs-de-lys and the cross flory.

Dún na Muir Fianna, Stronghold of. Name.
The Administrative Handbook, General Procedures for Submission C.5 requires evidence of support for submissions involving the name or armory of an active branch from a majority of the active members of the branch. No such evidence of support was enclosed with this submission. Additionally, the grammar appears to be incorrect. It would appear that the name should be Dún na Féinne Mara.

Eikdal, Shire of. Name and device. Gules, a longhouse between in pale two laurel wreaths argent.
The Administrative Handbook, General Procedures for Submission C.5 requires evidence of support for submissions involving the name or armory of an active branch from a majority of the active members of the branch. No such evidence of support was enclosed with this submission. No documentation has been presented that this rendition of a "longhouse" is either standard or the most common form. Some documentation on the form of Viking longhouses was presented by Lord Batonvert. This submission does not match any of the versions in that documentation.

Elrik of Sutherland. Device. Sable, two men mounted on horses passant addorsed argent, and a flame issuant from base proper.
Although the LOI noted the submitter has been advised to draw more yellow in flame, this is effectively a "base rayonny gules, fimbriated Or". Similar charges tinctured in this fashion have been returned in the past. If he wishes to redraw it with a real base of flames (gules with yellow throughout as well as along the edges of the rayonny) we will be happy to reconsider this proposal.

Fayrouze bin Numair al-Kadar. Name.
The documentation for the name was extremely weak. The Melting Pot Book of Baby Names does not appear to be the kind of source that we should use in the SCA for documenting Period names or name elements. Lord Laurel was only able to find Fayruz in one other (modern) source. No one else, including Lord Laurel, was able to find either Numair or al-Kadar, with the possible exception of "al-Qaadir", an attribute of Allah. This last is not acceptable in this form as part of a name. ("'Abd al-Qaadir", "servant of the Omnipotent") would be the standard form.

George of Lancaster. Name and device. Sable, a bend dovetailed between a griffin and a rose Or.
The Administrative Handbook, Protected Items I., states that "to preserve the historic distinction between an individual's society identity and his or her identity outside the Society, no item will be registered to a submitter if it is identical to an item used by the submitter legally or in common use outside the Society." RfS V.2 notes that addition or removal of adjectives does not constitute difference. Thus, the submitted name is effectively identical to the submitters use name outside the Society, George Lancaster. The device conflicts with Piers (Papworth, p. 218), Sable, a bend raguly between two unicorns heads erased Or. There is one CVD for the change of type of the secondaries; none for the difference between dovetailed and raguly.

Marina Zanne. Device. Per pale gules and sable, two ram's heads respectant Or.
Conflict with Quentin Wrenguard ap Phys, (SCA) Azure, two ram's heads erased combattant Or. There is only one CVD for the changes to the field.

Phuill mor na Grain, Canton of. Device. Per chevron inverted azure and Or, in chief on a sun Or a trident sable and in base a laurel wreath vert.
The name was returned on the June 1991 LoAR. As holding names cannot be used for groups, we have to return the device.

Raven of Heronsmarsh. Device. Or, a raven volant sable and a base wavy azure, overall a bordure purpure.
The primary charge is drawn in an extremely naturalistic trian aspect. This has been grounds for return since the tenure of Wilhelm von Schlüssel. Please ask the submitter to redraw in a standard heraldic volant position.

Susan of the Golden Heart. Badge for House Griffin and Rose. Azure, on a lozenge between four garden roses argent, a griffin sejant erect maintaining an estoile azure.
The Rules for Submission XI.4 prohibit charging a lozenge with more than one charge. The griffin and estoile are two charges.

Torres d'Yvorie, Leornung-hus. Name and device. Purpure, a tower and on a chief embattled argent a laurel wreath purpure.
The name violates RfS III.2.a, which states "each phrase may contain only one language and all the words in that phrase must be grammatically correct. Anglo Saxon and Old French are different languages. Additionally, no petition from the submitters was included, as required by the Administrative Handbook, C.5. (No conflicts were noted for the device.)

CALONTIR

Ian Michael O'Shaughnessey. Device. Per pale sable and gules, two dolphins hauriant respectant Or.

Conflict with Atfield (Papworth, p. 838), Per chevron sable and argent, two dolphins hauriant respecting each other Or. There is only one CVD for the changes to the field.

Nasir Abd-al-Kaniel. Name.
No documentation was submitted supporting the translation of "kaniel" as meaning spear (and it doesn't show up in any of Lord Laurel's dictionaries).

EAST

Morgan de Grey. Name appeal.

Part V of the Rules for Submission states "Names need to be distinguished from each other both in there written form and when heard in announcements." Morgan and Morton, de and the, are not sufficiently distinguishable when heard in announcements. RfS V.4.a. notes that spelling variants, however radical, which do not substantially change the pronunciation are not sufficient for difference, and then gives the example of "Friederich" and "Vrydrich", a large difference in spelling and the loss of a syllable, but insufficient for difference. A number of commenters appear to believe that if two names are derived from different roots, then they do not conflict no matter how much alike they may sound when pronounced. If I may quote Lord Batonvert: "It has absolutely nothing to do with any linguistic connections between the names; if they sound to similar, they conflict, and their etymology is irrelevant."

MERIDIES

Bébinn an Ghleanna. Device. Argent, on a bend vert between a cross crosslet fitchy and a cat sejant erect guardant sable, three trefoils palewise argent.

Conflict with May (Papworth, p. 277), Argent, on a bend vert between two bucks heads cabossed sable, three roses of the first, and with Lloyd (Combined Ordinary, p. 78), Argent, on a bend vert three wolves heads erased argent. In each case there is only one CVD for the change to type of the secondaries. If the client would make the secondaries on this proposal identical (two crosses or two cats), we could apply X.4.j.2. and grant the second CVD for change to type of the tertiaries against both these arms.

Blackmoore, Shire of. Name.
Conflict with Blackmoore, name of the second supplement published by TSR games to the original Dungeons and Dragons. The Administrative Handbook Protected Items F notes that locations which play a significant role in the action of the modern literary work (of any genre) in which they appear will be protected. As a consequence, in spite of the five English Blackmoors, we are having to return this for conflict with the TSR entity.

Gareth Cunedda. Device. Argent, on a pale sable between six roses gules, slipped, seeded and barbed vert, a sword proper, a bordure embattled counterchanged.
With four types of charge and five tinctures, not to mention the complex line of division and the counterchanging of the pale, this exceeds the rule of thumb for complexity as established in XIII.1.a.

Ian Chattan. Device. Vert, a thistle within a bordure flory Or.
Conflict with Virgina Brightangel (SCA), Vert, a thistle slipped flexed-reflexed, head to dexter, and in canton a mullet, all Or. There is one CVD for the change to type of the secondary, but the posture of the thistles is nearly identical with the exception of some waviness of the thistle's stem on Virginia's device.

MIDDLE

Duane of the Falls. Name.

The Administrative Handbook, Protected Items I., states that "to preserve the historic distinction between an individual's society identity and his or her identity outside the Society, no item will be registered to a submitter if it is identical to an item used by the submitter legally or in common use outside the Society." RfS V.2 notes that addition or removal of adjectives does not constitute difference. Thus, the submitted name is effectively identical to the submitters use name outside the Society, Duane Falls.

Kirsten Thorsteinsdottir. Device. Per chevron azure and argent, two rivenstars argent and issuant from base a lion's head gules.
Conflict with Alarikr af Stjarnaheim (SCA), Per chevron throughout azure and argent, two compass stars and a pithon embowed counterchanged. There is only one CVD for changing the type and tincture of the charge in base. Secondarily the "rivenstars" were drawn so offset as to be nearly unrecognizable as such, and several commenters questioned the acceptability of this charge for use by anyone besides the Barony of Rivenstar.

Margarete aus dem Schwarzwald. Name.
Conflict with the already registered Margaret von dem Schwarzwald. Changing the connecting article from von to aus is not enough.

WEST

Adriana nic Aífe de Winterhawke.

No name forms were received. Additionally, the locative is highly improbable. Dropping the particle "de" would probably be sufficient to answer the problem.

Eric Alard. Device. Azure, on a bend argent, between a mullet of four points pierced Or, and three rustres argent, a sword azure.
Conflict with U.S. 405th Infantry Regiment (Military Ordinary, No. 231), Azure, a bend argent voided. There is a CVD for the addition of the secondaries but nothing for the change to type only of the tertiaries. Revised X.4.j.2(b) only applies with identical secondaries.

Jesse of Ramscrag. Device. Azure, a pair of ram's horns and a compass star Or.
Conflict with Paul of Sunriver (SCA) Azure, a compass star Or. There is one CVD for the addition of the ram's horns.

Rosalynde y Corgwyn. Device. Vert, a key bendwise sinister, wards to chief Or, between two Corgi's statant proper.
The secondaries, reddish-brown on the green field, are color on color, which violates RfS VIII.2.b.i., the rule of contrast.

Scannal Alpin. Device. Or, a stag at gaze sable, a bordure gules.
Conflict with McCartney, Or, a stag trippant within a bordure gules, as cited in the LoI. There is one CVD for the tincture of the primary, but per X.4.h turning the head and moving the position of one leg is insufficient for the second. Also conflicts with Strachan (Lyon I, no. 5309), Or, a stag at gaze azure attired sable within a bordure gules. There is only one CVD for the tincture of the primary.

Stephan of Bellatrix. Device. Sable, on a bend Or, three compass stars palewise gules, overall a label of three points argent.
Conflict with Carswell (Papworth, p. 197), Sable, a bend Or, overall a label of five points argent. Conflict also with the registered arms of Paul of Bellatrix. There is but one CVD for the addition of the label. Without a letter of permission to conflict there is no way that we can register this. [While the LoI stated that his Grace has given his son permission to conflict, no letter granting such has been received by Laurel. "Non scripta, non est."]
The grandfather clause cannot apply in cases where the submitted arms have a conflict to which the original device would not be subject. Since his father's arms do not conflict with Carswell, but only his own, the grandfather clause cannot be applied here. With respect to the conflict with Carswell, the client has a couple of simple options: (1) change the tincture of the label to ermine or Or; or (2) use the device as submitted with permission from his father without registering it with the College. As the base coat is already registered to his father, the son's use of it differenced by a label is an entirely appropriate form of display.

Stephen MacAlpine. Device. Or, a lion rampant to sinister guardant within a sash in annulo, knotted in base, sable.
The sash is not a recognized heraldic charge. Additionally, the submitter's form indicates that the precise form of sash is to be a "karate belt with the white stripes". We need evidence that this belt has not only been earned by the submitter, but that it is a Period charge.

THE FOLLOWING SUBMISSIONS HAVE BEEN PENDED:

EAST

Rose the Riotous. Device. Per bend sinister argent and azure, a garden rose bendwise sinister, slipped and leaved, azure and a goutte d'eau.

Blazoned in the LOI as proper, the rose is azure. This is pended until the December Laurel meeting for conflict research.


Return to the LoAR Index Page

Last Updated: $Date: 2004/05/20 21:01:19 $GMT

Copyright © 1997 Society for Creative Anachronism, Inc.